Thursday, 18 December 2014

Mythology Parading as Opinion – Mike Yardley and Restorative Justice

by Kim Workman
 The great enemy of truth is very often not the lie -- deliberate, contrived and dishonest -- but the myth -- persistent, persuasive and unrealistic. Too often we hold fast to the clichés of our forebears. We subject all facts to a prefabricated set of interpretations. We enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought.
President John Kennedy

Commencement Address at Yale University, June 11 1962 [1]
 This is the time of the year when social commentators compile their personal list of Media Awards; the Best, the Worst, the best piece of investigative journalism, and so on. 
I have always lacked  the analytical incentive to classify, file, and rank media stories so that  I could come up with a personal list of awards in the area of crime and justice.  On quick reflection,   Nigel Latta’s documentary ‘Nigel Latta:  Behind Bars’, was the most thorough treatment on prisons in New Zealand society that I have seen.      The range of contributors to the documentary  and the broad spectrum of views was outstanding. 

The piece that I found the most annoying (until yesterday) was Seven Sharp’s  cavalier and arrogant treatment of Justspeak’s Lydia Nobbs, who was interviewed about its outstanding publication, “Unlocking Prisons – ReducingNew Zealand’s Prison Population”.  I lambasted it in an earlier blog , ‘Seven Sharp and Penal Policy – Let’s Do theTime Warp Again.' 

I was irritated because Mike Hosking, who usually does his  homework and bases his opinions on good information, failed to do so on this occasion.  Rethinking has always taken the view that journalists and paid commentators have a social, professional and ethical responsibility to base comment and opinion on fact.   I made the point that news and media comment is more readily available and influential , than ever before and that;

 “while viewers have become more aware of crime and punishment issues, their framework of understanding is shaped by the media.  When Seven Sharp makes ‘authoritative’ statements about prisons, punishment and public opinion – the public takes them at face value.”

Media should present a wide range of views about matters of public interest, and media commentators are as entitled as anyone else to voiice a personal opinion .  However, one would expect journalists and professional media to meet a different and higher standard, than those whose responses are nothing much more than a gut reaction to an issue.  I was annoyed with Mike Hosking for failing to reach that standard.

However, his place at the top of my personal media award list for lazy and irresponsible journalism, is now occupied by Press columnist, Mike Yardley.  He is an Award-winning broadcaster on Travel and Current Affairs and  syndicated columnist and  correspondent on radio, in print and online. His recent Opinion Piece,  ‘Restorative Justice of Little Benefit to Victims”  was probably a response to Restorative Justice Aotearoa’s media release of 8 December,  ‘Victims to have a greater say on restorative justice’


Mike Yardley was beaten to the draw by Manawatu Standard’s Jono Galuszka, who did a great job of  raising concerns about the new legislation, in an article New laws may lead to court delays’ .  Jono took the trouble to speak to people.  He talked with Mike Hinton of Restorative Justice Aotearoa, and a Horowhenua couple,  John and Lynda Timmer-Arends whose son had been murdered.  The Timmer-Arends  had two concerns which are raised regularly about restorative justice.  First, the recurring belief that people will be forced into a restorative justice conference against their wishes.  It is always a voluntary process, and one in which either the victim and offender can choose not to participate, at the outset, or during the process.  The second prevailing view, is that it should not be used in serious cases.  That was a widely held belief twenty years ago – the evidence since then has proved us wrong.  Restorative justice is more effective in crimes of violence than in property crimes.  The more serious the violence, the more likelihood that restorative justice will provide satisfaction to the victim, and reduce reoffending on the part of the offender. 

Mike Yardley’s opinion piece, which followed a week later,  ‘Restorative Justice of Little Benefit to Victims’ (16th December), (16th December 2014) is one of the most appalling and inaccurate pieces of criminal justice journalism that I have read in recent times. 

Restorative Justice of Little Value to Victims

OPINION: Pop your head into any Canterbury court and you'll find the wheels of justice are grinding ever slower.

Last week heralded a quiet revolution to the sentencing procedures in district courts, whereby virtually every case involving victims that results in a guilty plea will be adjourned.
No longer will offenders be swiftly sentenced after a guilty finding. The presiding judge is now compelled to park up the case, under Section 24a of the Sentencing Act, while considerations are given to convening a restorative-justice conference.

This new touchy-feely provision, which applies to offending right across the board, will surely compound what can already be the glacial pace of court, as restorative justice providers set about determining the willingness of offenders and victims to have a come-together.

The Ministry of Justice is spending mega-bucks contracting teams of restorative-justice facilitators to implement this bureaucratic malarkey.

Restorative Justice Aotearoa, the national body of facilitators, is heaping praise on the change, which pre-supposes every victim wants to face his or her offender over tea and biscuits.

The system's new opt-in position is a bit like KiwiSaver, whereby victims will have to actively opt out of a restorative-justice process.  Plus, the court must adjourn proceedings to allow facilitators time to readily identify a victim.
 Let's suppose I have pleaded guilty to possessing methamphetamine for supply. Is every prospective buyer and their families, who will be the real victims, going to be somehow corralled into a conference?
What about the recidivist burglar of 30 properties? And just how much time and money is going to be zapped trying to cajole people to take part?

The Sensible Sentencing Trust is pillorying the new regime, arguing that restorative justice should only apply in situations where it's possible for the victim to have restored to them whatever they may have lost as a result of an offence. For example, the theft of a bike or damage to their letterbox.

But serious violence, really?

Sensible Sentencing's biggest beef is that these restorative justice conferences are actually offender-driven. They will be taken into consideration as part of sentencing, potentially resulting in brownie-points and lighter penalties.
Doesn't that make a mockery of the much-vaunted philosophy of placing the victim at the centre our justice system?   
The New South Wales model strikes me as a far fairer approach, whereby victim-offender conferences can occur only post-sentence, and often in conjunction with rehabilitation programmes at the end of a sentence.

Justice delayed is indeed justice denied.

We've just added another overcooked, money-sucking monkey wrench to its timely delivery.
 - The Press

 There was a prompt on-line response from Professor Chris Marshall, the Diana Unwin Chair in Restorative Justice, Victoria University of Wellington

I wonder whether Mike Yardley has ever talked to victims who have been through what he derides as a "touchy feely" process of meeting with those who injured them "over tea and biscuits"? I sincerely doubt it. Nor has he probably acquainted himself with the masses of international research that shows over 80% of victims who attend restorative justice meetings express satisfaction with the process and would recommend it to others. Restorative justice, unlike the conventional justice system, approaches offending from the perspective of victims and seeks primarily to address their needs. And no one is ever "corralled into a conference"; the process is entirely voluntary. As for the assumption that restorative justice may be ok for theft of a bike or damage of a letter box but not for serious violence, the research shows just the opposite. The greater the harm suffered by victims, the greater the potential of restorative justice to help. Its all too easy for arm chair critics to decry the process as offender driven and of little help to victims. Sit with actual victims and participate in actual conferences and things look different. Recent changes to legislation will certainly bring many challenges to court processes. But they are, in my view, undoubtedly moves in the right direction - and primarily for victims.
Professor Chris Marshall,
The Diana Unwin Chair in Restorative Justice,
Victoria University of Wellington

Mike Yardley’s views come straight out of the Sensible Sentencing Trust’s Songbook;  these specious and unsubstantiated claims have been part of its lexicon for years.  He was  quick to take up Sensible Sentencing's beef that restorative justice conferences are  offender-driven.  However, his claim that the recent changes in legislation make “a mockery of the much-vaunted philosophy of placing the victim at the centre our justice system” don't stand up to even the most superficial scrutiny.
 
He refers to Section 24a of the Sentencing Act, but fails to mention the other measures that were passed under the legislation.  The former Minister of Justice, the Hon Judith Collins, when she announced that the legislation had been passed on 27th May, rightly claimed that the  legislation "put victims at the heart of New Zealand’s criminal justice system".  Her  media release “Bill to Strengthen Victims Rights Passes Into Law’ made it clear that the legislation:

  • Made agencies more accountable for delivering quality services for victims; 
  • Required the Ministry of Justice to develop a Victims Code that outlines victims’ rights and the service available to victims;
  • W idened the eligibility of victims able to register on the Victims Notification System so that they can stay informed about the offender;
  • Extended the rights of victims to also apply to victims of youth crime.
Ms Collins also pointed out that the Bill widened the scope of the Victim’s Impact Statement to give victims of serious offences the right to read their statement to the court.

Follow the New South Wales System?  Where Did That Come From?

At the end of the article, Mike Yardley promotes the NSW restorative justice system as the preferred model, ‘whereby victim-offender conferences can occur only post-sentence, and often in conjunction with rehabilitation programmes at the end of a sentence.'
   
It is clear that he has never bothered to study the NSW restorative justice system  - this is a comment that comes straight from Sensible Sentencing’s website, which has recommended for some time that New Zealand should adopt the NSW system,  which (it claims) “has not been plagued with some of the problems experienced here in New  Zealand”.  In order to do that, New Zealand would need to comply with a number of caveats, which are outlined on the SST website.
  
Earlier this year I checked my understanding of the NSW system with Kate Milner , Director Restorative Justice, Department of Corrective Services, New South Wales.  I sent her the list of ‘caveats', and asked her to comment on whether they were an accurate representation of the NSW system. 

Here is her response and correction of SST’s 'caveats'; 
  • SST Caveat No 1:  In New South Wales, restorative justice is victim driven, rather than offender driven, and focuses  on the offender having an obligation to their victim to try and repair the harm done by their crime.
  • CSNSW’s Response:  CSNSW accepts referral from either victims of crime or offenders.  A small number of victims of crime specifically say that they would only participate if the process is offender initiated as this would reflect remorse and responsibility taking. About one in eight offender referrals results in either a victim-offender conference or an alternate RJ process (VOM / indirect mediation).
  • SST Caveat  No 2: In New South Wales, restorative justice takes place post-sentence rather than pre-sentence, and therefore will not be taken into consideration as part of sentencing, and cannot be rushed through prior to sentencing just to earn a sentence reduction.
  • CSNSW Response:  Whilst our practice is post-sentence, in NSW there are pre-sentence programs: Youth Justice Conferencing (Juvenile Justice) and Forum Sentencing (Attorney Generals).  We are of the belief that best practice RJ should be available to victims of crime at any stage of the CJ process.
  • SST Caveat No 3:  In New South Wales, Restorative Justice meetings are combined with and only occur in conjunction with rehabilitation programmes at the end of a sentence.
  • CSNSW Response:  CSNSW accepts post-sentence referrals at any time.
  • SST Caveat No 4:  In New South Wales, restorative justice outcomes have no influence on parole hearings – no reports are `submitted to the parole board regarding restorative justice meeting outcomes when considering release.
  • CSNSW Response:  Objective closure summaries, with no subjective comment regarding the writer’s perceived success of victim offender conference are available to the State Parole Authority.
  • Sensible Sentencing Trust also considers that no person with a serious criminal record should work in Restorative Justice as a facilitator or in any other voluntary or paid capacity. Everybody must be screened and full Police checks carried out, along with mandatory training. That is already the situation in New Zealand, with full Police checks and enquiries made, so that consideration may be given to the suitability of persons to train as a restorative justice facilitator.  The same approach applies in NSW. 
  •  CCNSW Response:  All CSNSW staff undergo rigorous criminal record checks and RJ facilitators receive formal training in the TJA conferencing model and on the job training in the practice of RJ in response to serious crimes committed by adults.
In conclusion, Kate Milner had this to say:
“Research recently undertaken by UNSW indeed supports the fact that our model is highly successful in addressing the unmet justice needs of victims of crime and offenders. We however strongly support a vision for RJ, that is inclusive of the person responsible and those directly harmed, being available at every juncture of the justice process.”
Those who are interested , can read more about their approach on the new CSNSWwebsite.  

In other words, Sensible Sentencing’s caveats are a fabrication.  Why then,  did Mike Yardley express a view that is totally inaccurate and untrue? 

The answer is simple.  The Sensible Sentencing Trust is a haven for lazy media professionals.  Go to Sensible Sentencing, and you will get what lax journalists want – provocative headlines that sell newspapers.   On this occasion, as has happened before, Sensible Sentencing became a source of ‘expert’ opinion, while criminal justice professionals and those  highly knowledgeable in this area were overlooked.  Populist attitudes trump research any day. 



Mike Yardley has been caught with his pants down, making claims about the New South Wales restorative justice system which are untrue; but it was  Garth McVicar  who loosened his belt.  Anyone who chooses to accept  Sensible Sentencing’s claims without checking at the source, deserve what they get. 

Rethinking Crime and Punishment position is clear.  It  is in the business of  informing citizens, the mass media, practitioners, policy-makers and politicians about what works in reducing crime. In the process it highlights the flaws in quick and dirty research, identifies populist measures that have no evidential basis, and identify approaches that will get better results. 
What do we want in our Christmas stocking?  Informed public opinion that encourages truth telling and honesty. No more ‘knowledgeable claims  unsupported by evidence.  Let’s make 2015 a year in which professional journalists do their homework, and put out informed views that have basis in fact. 





[1] http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=29661

1038 Comments on this Post:

«Oldest   ‹Older   1001 – 1038 of 1038   Newer›   Newest»
RalphSelton said...

After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.

Palipreschool.org
Information
Click Here

Walter white said...

This is the perfume ingredient oud, which is also called agarwood, oudh, agalocha, aloeswood, or eaglewood. Agarwood is a rarity on many fronts. Because the resin is only triggered by the mold, it's estimated that a total of 2 percent of these trees produce it. Not only does this raise the price of the oil, the wood is also one of the most expensive on the market. Additionally, many of these trees are now threatened species.Buy oud perfume from Olfa Originals. We have a wide variety of Luxury fragrances.We believe in bringing the finest formulated fragrances to the wearers, lending them a touch of class and sophistication.

Walter white said...

Treat your hair with love with Spotstyl Pure Silk Scrunchies. Ultra soft, Strand Sensitive, Extra Gentle Scrunchies. Shop Now! Cash on Delivery. Free Shipping. Wide Surface Area. Prevents Hair Damage. Extra Soft Elastic. Services: Strand Sensitive, Anti-Frizz.Buy silk scrunchies from Spotstyl. Recommended by hairstylists & beauty experts alike, our pure silk scrunchies minimise hair loss, prevents split ends, fight frizz & leave your hair lustrous & crease-free!

Walter white said...

Benefits of cinnamon (dalchini) milk include warming and soothing of the body, and positive effects on alertness, memory, and insight. It can help you recall things that you usually end up forgetting and also improve your response time.Prahna brings you high quality, nutrient-rich superfoods sourced directly and sustainably from our partner farmers.Buy turmeric latte from Prahna Superfoods.We Provide 100% Organic turmeric milk from Prahna superfoods.

Walter white said...

Lavanya strives to offer the best in fashion wear, jewellery and lifestyle products. From curating events to the launch of the eponymous fashion magazine in July 2019, the brand now goes a notch higher by reaching to a global clientele by way of an online platform. The philosophy of the brand is to grow by making every woman glow. Buy lavanya clothing from Lavanya

news said...

I really like your post, I always like to read a quality content having accurate information regarding the subject. Thanks for sharing. It is such a very amazing post.

Facebook login | omegle | Hotmail login | disneyplus.com login/begin| amazon.com/code

Jery Fox said...

It’s hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

Click Here
Visit Web
Mecanica-usa.com

Sophia Williams said...

Here I am for the first time, and I found beneficial information. Very nice and well-explained article. Thanks for sharing!

coinbase login
coinbase login
coinbase login

news said...

I really like your post, I always like to read a quality content having accurate information regarding the subject. Thanks for sharing. It is such a very amazing post.

disneyplus.com login/begin | Msn Hotmail

VanesaBell said...

An impressive share, I just given this onto a colleague who was doing a little analysis on this. And he in fact bought me breakfast because I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic. If possible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It is highly helpful for me. Big thumb up for this blog post!

Asami.mx
Information
Click Here

MariyamSimones said...

Your place is valueble for me. Thanks!....


Muzikspace.com
Information

Jame Smith said...

Our professional grant writing help online in Australia are experts in developing documents which help persuade your potential customers to choose products or services you offer.

GBPLUS said...

Osm! This post is very informative and effective. I got what I was looking for. Here to say thank you. Thanks for sharing FMWhatsapp valuable content.

anjalisingh said...

Hello , lovers of cricket welcome to our fantasy cricket application means fantasypower11 which is provide you online cricket information
any time to know all cricket match online ball to ball and over to over play cricket online.
play cricket online

Mitchel Cruze said...

The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought you have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

Doctorslounge
Website
Klik Disini

nickmiddleton010 said...

When installed in a kitchen space, they offer plenty of work storage, while still answering the higher aesthetics of modern design sensibility. They are the key to creating a contemporary interior design inside a kitchen. At Cabinet DIY, we bring you a wide range of cabinetry styles that are both functional and eye pleasing. modern kitchen cabinets

Eva said...


Nice and well explained blog thanks for sharing this information
Aol mail login
Coinbase pro login
BT Email Login
Capital one login
Chime login
Venmo login

Jennifer said...

Hi! this is nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such a wonderful informative information. I hope you will publish again such type of post. Also, please check out about
elan group |
elan real estate |
elan group |
elan group gurgaon |
Elan Empire Gurgaon |
empire sector 66 gurgaon |
elan sector 50 gurgaon

eddielydon said...

Our the purpose is to share the reviews about the latest Jackets,Coats and Vests also share the related Movies,Gaming, Casual,Faux Leather and Leather materials available Bane Coat

News tech new site said...

I want to mention this blog, have look at this blog, I felt awesome and I surely have bookmarked it. Fmovies | Fmovies

Patrika Jones said...

Amazon is the biggest e-commerce website in the world. If you are looking for the best deals for discount coupons feel free to visit us at amazon.com/code
Amazon is the biggest e-commerce website in the world. If you are looking for the best deals for discount coupons feel free to visit us at amazon.com/code

Realestate said...

With regards to commercial endeavours, there are various them underway. The Elan Empire Gurgaon project, which is being dispatched by the eminent Elan Group, is perhaps the most discussed commercial project that has been making news.
Elan Empire
Elan Empire

Jennifer said...

Hi! this is nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such a wonderful informative information. I hope you will publish again such type of post. Also, please check out about
AOL Mail Login |
AOL Mail Login |
AOL Mail Login

Mitchel Cruze said...

Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.

Myopportunity
Website
Klik Disini

Unknown said...

Hi! this is nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such a wonderful informative information. I hope you will publish again such type of

post.
Webroot.com/Safe |
Microsoft365.com/Setup

Realestate said...

Elan Empire Sector 66 is a project that aims to build high-end commercial spaces with ravishing interiors and much-needed amenities. Situated in the most luxurious locations, Elan is all set to make you astounded with its projects.


Chris ray said...

Wells Fargo: Provider of banking, mortgage, investing, credit card, and personal, small business, and commercial financial services.
wells fargo login | wells fargo login | wells fargo login

news said...

Great information you shared through this blog. Keep it up and best of luck for your future blogs and posts.

Msvcp140.dll Download

vcruntime140.dll download

Alger Ziggy said...

Very nice post, i certainly love this website, keep on it

Kiva.org
Information
Click Here

Unknown said...

I merely picked up your blog post a couple weeks ago i have actually been perusing this tool always. An individual has a lot of helpful tips at this point we absolutely love your lifestyle of a internet sites actually. Stick to the nice perform! Bandar Slot Terbesar

Media SEO said...

I merely picked up your blog post a couple weeks ago i have actually been perusing this tool always. An individual has a lot of helpful tips at this point we absolutely love your lifestyle of a internet sites actually. Stick to the nice perform! Sewa Bus Jogja Murah

Unknown said...

An impressive share, I just now with all this onto a colleague who had previously been doing small analysis within this. And then he the fact is bought me breakfast because I stumbled upon it for him.. smile. So i want to reword that: Thnx for that treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending any time to discuss this, Personally i think strongly about this and adore reading on this topic. If at all possible, as you become expertise, could you mind updating your website to comprehend details? It really is extremely ideal for me. Large thumb up with this writing! Sewa Bus Jogja Murah | Sewa Mobil Jogja Lepas Kunci

news said...


Great information you shared through this blog. Keep it up and best of luck for your future blogs and posts.

canon.com/ijsetup
Canon Printer Setup
ij.start.canon
Canon printer not responding
www.amazon.com/mytv

Jennifer said...

Hi! this is nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such a wonderful informative information. I hope you will publish again such type of post. Also, please check out about
Coinbase Pro Login |
Coinbase Pro Login |
Coinbase Pro Login |
Coinbase Pro Login |
Coinbase Pro Login |
Coinbase Support Number |
Coinbase Support Number

cyberads said...


Attractive part of content. I’d like to find out more? I’d care to find out more details.I have read so many content on the topic of the blogger lovers however this paragraph is truly a good post, keep it up. Jadwal Kapal Pelni | Jadwal Kapal Pelni Terbaru

cyberads said...


I merely picked up your blog post a couple weeks ago i have actually been perusing this tool always. An individual has a lot of helpful tips at this point we absolutely love your lifestyle of a internet sites actually. Stick to the nice perform! Jadwal Kapal Pelni | Jadwal Kapal Pelni Terbaru

nickmiddleton010 said...

Among all the options available for low-cost kitchen cabinets, perhaps RTA cabinets ensure the best quality. Superior wood and plywood are used to make RTA cabinets that offer you sturdy and beautiful cabinets that last longer than any readymade shaker cabinets. kitchen cabinets for sale

George Mark said...

Incredible blog here! It's mind boggling posting with the checked and genuinely accommodating data. Eurovision Peacoat

«Oldest ‹Older   1001 – 1038 of 1038   Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment