The media discussion around the conditional
discharge of Korotangi Paki, son of King
Tiheitia, has drawn both
public anger, and some useful
public discussion about the exercise of
judicial discretion. Korotangi Paki, 19,
had previously pleaded guilty to charges of burglary, theft and drink driving,
but was not convicted after his defence successfully argued that would ruin his
chances of succeeding to the Kingitanga throne.
It brought back memories of my policing days when from time to time,
young offenders were discharged without conviction on the grounds that a
conviction would have adverse consequences on their future career and
prospects. Law students seemed
particularly prone to causing minor destruction and mayhem, or drink driving. They
were usually represented in Court by
highly competent and very expensive counsel, and much to the chagrin of the
Police, were subsequently discharged
without conviction. Some years later these
young miscreants emerged as solid citizens, making both a positive contribution
to society and lots of money, successfully representing the next generation of
the legal profession who had fallen afoul of the law. It brought home to me the virtues of ‘second
chance’ redemption.
It wasn’t only
law students. Others of influence were
able to mount compelling reasons why on this one occasion, the Court should
exercise its mercy. I recall the two
sons of one of Wairarapa’s first families, being asked to leave Orisini’s
Restaurant after becoming very drunk and disorderly. They retaliated by rooting out the rose
bushes that grew in the small garden outside the restaurant. With the support of good legal advice, they
were discharged without conviction, and went on to become venerated citizens
who these days, produce some of the
country’s best wines – which I’m sure they never drink to excess.
Are Applications
for Discharge without Conviction Common?
Section 106, ofthe Sentencing Act 2002 provides that If
a person who is charged with an offence is found guilty or pleads guilty, the
court may discharge the offender without conviction. Some legal firms
specialise in making S.106 applications on behalf of clients, and claim
considerable success. Guardian Chambers for example say that:
“Members of Guardian Chambers have literally made 100’s of discharge
applications and have had outstanding success in avoiding criminal convictions
for their clients which has meant they can honestly place a tick in the ‘no’
box next to the question “Have you ever had a criminal conviction?” whether it
be contained in a travel document, a job application or any one of many
applications that they make in the course of their lives.”
Liberty Law provides this piece of additional advice to its clients:
“It is
essential to note that the court must not discharge an offender
without conviction unless the court is satisfied that the direct and indirect
consequences of a conviction would be out of all proportion to the gravity of
the offence. This test has been described by the Court of Appeal as “a gateway
through which any discharge without conviction must pass.”
I don’t know how
many offenders are successful in achieving a discharge without conviction, but
by all accounts, it is a common practise.
All one needs is money and a lawyer.
Why all the fuss?
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgNVsvnDJrqaUNod3H3tfqAHJa1hYLXcFWkx_IEErEF22hnNLWxW89UDc_rDHQRSGOgCy5WsNctL5PuurRkl3VuSUlW8Y-cAJHhuJu6MwlKxioxFV26gfU9g3zVxDzP5Nu6qPgSrV7Y5_Qh/s1600/The+too+hard+basket.png)
The graph below
gives an indication of the differential treatment of Māori within the judicial
system. (1) The dark blue portion represents the Maori population at 14% of the general popultion. It then shows the over-representation of Maori at each stage of the judicial process.
S
Second, Korotangi is not a typical first-time offender. While his offending is fairly low-level, his profile suggests that he is a troubled young man, who unless constrained will descend into a cycle of offending driven by alcohol dependency.
Third, he is the son of the King Tuheitia Paki, whose span of influence extends well beyond Tainui iwi and the Kingitanga movement. It is an influence which exceeds that of the wealthy parents of law students, and even possibly, Wairarapa’s first families
Public Reaction In Support of the
Decision
Media Coverage
on this issue was evenly balanced. On NewstalkZB, Mike Hosking interviewed lawyer Annette Sykes, who did an excellent job of explaining the reasons why the Judge’s decision was
appropriate. First, the three
co-offenders had been previously sentenced and were discharged without
conviction. In such cases, there needs to be equality of treatment. Second, that ‘Marae Justice’ had already been
dispensed i.e. Korotangi has had to make significant reparation, is required to
address his alcohol problem, and must walk a long and difficult journey back to
redemption. He has brought the name of
his father, and Tainui into serious disrepute.
The shame was not confined to the offender, but is now collectively
experienced by the tribe.
Newstalk ZB's’s interview of law lecturer Kylee Quince confirmed the view that while he escaped without conviction, he did not
escape punishment. As Kylee comments;
"His particular
position is unusual but looking to someone's future life and career prospects,
those are always things that a judge is able to and appropriately does take
account of."
Public Reaction Against the Decision
The media reaction against Judge Phillipa
Cunningham’s decision, was swift, and included criticism of Korotangi, the
Judge, and disparaging remarks about the Kingitanga movement itself. Whale Oil’s Cameron Slater referred to Korotangi as a ‘royal ratbag’, and the influence of the ‘bro-racracy and Māori royalty’. The decision ‘pandered to the sensitivities
of fake royalty’ and Phillippa Cunningham has shown that she is a ‘dud judge’.
In
similar vein, at No Minister, The Veteran’s post (which misspelt Korotangi’s Name) claimed that the
decision was ‘ favour based on colour of skin and supposed
family status’.. Lindsay Mitchell in her
blog ‘Māori Prince hides under Daddy’s Korowai’ took the unusual step of acknowledging her
own conviction over drink driving at an early age, being fined and disqualified
and commented that she was ‘deeply ashamed.
She explains:
“I
got a drink/driving charge at a similar age. Just over the limit, fined $300
and disqualified for six months, I lost my job. I was deeply ashamed. It was a
rock bottom point in my life but accepting the consequences turned me around.” She takes the view that “his father should let
him face the same fall-out as anyone else. Particularly that faced by many a
less privileged Māori. Classism is alive and kicking within Māoridom.”
The Differential Impact of Public Shaming
The one
aspect of this case, that distinguishes it from most s.106 applications, and
one which
is not well understood, is the differential impact of shaming. Lindsay’s final paragraph provides a useful
platform from which to examine that issue more closely.
In early New Zealand, public
sanctioning quickly became the norm.
Māori approved the use of the
stocks as punishment for theft and similar crimes. Public punishments and the infliction of
bodily pain were seen in some cases as culturally appropriate. The death penalty was also seen to be
appropriate for serious crime, with Chiefs demanding the right to kill in
certain cases. At the same time, there
was tribal resistance to the imposition of severe sentences on chiefs or
persons of significant mana. So to that
extent, Lindsay is right – the Māori expectation in the early days was that
people of significance should not be subjected to indignity or disrespect – their
mana would have been disproportionately undermined by that treatment.
Public displays of punishment were moral
degradation ceremonies in which the crowd played a key role in the renewal of
community values through their recognition of the offender’s wrongdoing.(2)
Public flogging was part of New
Zealand’s early history, but was
abandoned by the 1860’s. While the criminal justice system steadily moved from the public infliction of pain, which was seen as degrading and counter- productive to reformation, the public were not prepared to surrender totally, its appetite for public shaming.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgOUfUXvuLKFc41imetqaDjG4abwohQiC05RRwAHOOwaGv0_WD-G7y8bPh8U8JpmKzQW3RaK1_9tF5j29WFuzCGTIzUFGuDy4BGxpL3HQmIx7hJaNX4TL-sot8QhqUE1us0BNV1NtEa85Sc/s1600/Nga+Pepeha++Nga+Tipuna.png)
There
is a substantial ‘shaming’ literature, which identifies the impact of public
shaming on reoffending. The most
effective public shaming occurs within tribal societies or communities with
high social cohesion. Public shaming of
white collar criminals, normally law-abiding citizens (think Lindsay) and organisational crime i.e. crimes of the
powerful, have been shown to be effective.(3)
This
research accords with my policing experience, in which I recall two incidents
in which offenders came from closed, highly -cohesive communities. The shaming impact in both cases was
significant. The first was a 15 year old
Chinese boy, whose widowed mother was struggling to provide. In his desire to avoid being the only boy at
the school social wearing short pants, he shoplifted a pair of long trousers –
and got caught. The response from the
Chinese community was both immediate and severe. Elders from the Chinese
community visited me, not to ask for the exercise of Police discretion, but to
assure me that they were taking measures of their own. He was stood down as a youth leader,
prohibited from attending Chinese social functions and required to work on
community projects for the next two years.
The elders visited the department store with the young man, to render a
formal apology, and provide reparation. The
Police administered a warning, secure in the knowledge that this young man was
being held accountable to the people he had shamed.
The
second example involved a Tongan Police recruit, who on the night of his
graduation got very drunk, and interfered with a police inquiry into a traffic
accident outside a hotel. He was on the
verge of being arrested, but as the Senior Sergeant in charge, I decided to
apply discretion, and instead, called a meeting with his fanau and church
leaders the next day, to voice my displeasure at his behaviour. I learnt subsequently that his uncles
administered a beating of such severity that he spent the next week on his back. By all accounts, he resumed his Police
career, and made a solid contribution.
In
those examples, shaming had its place.
In Lindsay’s recounted experience, hers was a personal shame, but in
addition was shared by those to whom she felt accountable. However, the extent to
which personal, family or tribal shaming becomes a matter of wide public
knowledge has the potential to impact negatively on the offender. Interestingly, Lindsay provided a link in her
blog, to an incident involving Korotangi three years ago, when he crashed a
car. The disadvantage
and downside of status and prestige, or being related to someone with those
characteristics, means that incidents which normally would merit three lines in
the local newspaper, suddenly become national news.
Lindsay’s
view is that “Korotangi’s father should
let him face the same fall-out as anyone else.
Particularly that faced by many a less privileged Māori.”
If
there is one thing that is painfully clear, it is that the shaming of the
powerless in the absence of positive reinforcement by the offender’s community has
the opposite effect to that of offenders who live in cohesive and closely
integrated communities. Braithwaite and Drahos put it this way: z
“The problem with public shaming is that it
leaps from that truth to policies that stigmatise and degrade. It is not simply
that stigmatisation is a less effective way of making people feel ashamed of
wrongdoing than reintegrative shaming; it actually makes them feel less
ashamed. It is not that respectful disapproval within communities of care works
while stigmatisation does not; stigmatisation actually increases crime.”(4)
On the basis
of current ‘public shaming’ research,
the management of any situation in which either the victim or the
defendant are, through widespread publicity, likely to be shamed in a way which
stigmatises them and their family or whānau, should be subject to judicial management. For low level marginalised offenders,
widespread television coverage will only serve to further stigmatise and
increase the likelihood of future reoffending.
We have
reached a situation todaywhen the practise of public shaming, while
divorced from the public imposition of pain, is still practised. The vast majority of New Zealanders no longer
exist in tribal communities, including most Māori. There
are a handful of small rural communities
that enjoy a high level of social cohesion.
As the current research on inequality shows, we have become largely a
society of ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ – but the practise of public shaming
persists regardless ; and the responsibility for its exercise has shifted from
the judiciary to the media.
The
Kingitanga Movement
Some of
the commentators took the opportunity to ‘dismiss’ the Kingitanga as ‘ersatz
royalty’. On the contrary, it is a
strongly cohesive. The Kīngitanga
parliament, the Kauhanganui, was established at Maungakawa about 1890, and today it’s 129 members, represent
65 Tainui marae. Twenty six of those
marae are Poukai marae which have
been regularly visited by the Māori King
or Queen since the 1860’s. Poukai hui
host an annual circuit
of visits by the king that includes feasting, cultural performances and tribal
discussion. The level of social cohesion is extraordinary, and the
korero at those hui is to the point, hard hitting, at times ruthless.
It is those 65 marae to whom Korotangi will be accountable for his future behaviour. Some of the marae personalities will compose waiata pao or ditties, about Korotangi. The term ‘paopao’ means gossip, and many pao are gossip songs which treat the misfortunes of their subjects in very direct and often slanderous terms. He may acquire a new nickname or two, perhaps addressed not directly to him, but about him. I am surprised that former Minister of Māori Affairs and Ngapuhi kaumatua Dover Samuels chose to voice his disagreement with the decision through the Pākehā media, referring to the Judge as suffering from ‘cultural hypnosis’. I would pay good money to hear Dover put his views at a Kingitanga Poukai, where the issue could be debated in accordance with tradition.
Whakahoki Mauri - Restoring Community Balance
Through this process
his father, whānau and community must share in his shame and
indignity. But overriding all that, will
be a collective desire for Korotangi to take responsibility, be held
accountable; safe in the knowledge that at all times he will have the support
of all of Tainui in beating a difficult and lengthy path back to
redemption. It will take strength and courage to accept that his actions have brought about shame. Once this level of consciousness has been reached, restorative action can begin.
Māori tradition also recognises that
there is a point at which public shaming should stop. This is found in the proverb “Kia ata akiaki
I ahau, he kai ka mate kei te hara o te kaki” –
“Dwell not on my faults, for
the desire for food dies at the throat of sin.”
Continual censure can cause such shame that one can no longer eat and
therefore can no longer make a contribution to the people. After this there was only suicide or
death.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEheUL1aGIFE-Jr7aWWIRfXzrZ_FWSM9be_Bs2yncabnLNOT-aDHRfkNyENJ4vIpLF6Pf7VbQCXfO1MM8rGvw8cze7vS7RFFRaDuCz7xOB4l2r4PgJJW0QUGnx5CQGut5cKpSGF9uqwgOBQG/s1600/Forgive+us+our+trespasses.png)
If
we are committed to being ‘Smart on Crime’, why not consider
instead, the
impact that public shaming has on those people who don’t live within a
strong tribal construct, or isolated rural communities. Those who are marginalised, and described as
the ‘dark underclass’. What is the
impact of public shaming on that group?
Over
the last twenty years, there has emerged a body of research, which is directed
at developing strategies for ex-prisoners and offenders from marginalised
communities to socially integrate back into the community(5) It is
on this group that public shaming has adverse impacts on the
efforts of offenders to desist from crime, and make major changes in their
lives. Besides
the legal implications of having a prior conviction, a conviction record poses an obstacle to reintegration (e.g. access to
jobs, housing, education, loss of parental rights). The conviction record
reinforces a criminal identity, is a
major ground for social exclusion, and makes it difficult to adopt a new identity,
i.e. that of a ‘law abiding citizen’.(6)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgq1Ho7k_zsIlcwGJjYapPJXcBZs8s_Yv7bQJx3LQjnnAliR0VihTd1BOcc3vaFh_LU-4B6h9WoFMmGfvAttSy_grgZHmj8-YfHYIvyR1qPNzc6vx9fFteyA5KzKq6bnjkEuj-VJ6dyfDWR/s1600/Think+outside+the+stigma.png)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjWcLnEoIhoF7qvOlMGtfIr2hp8Seg1tG9QOaFrqyJVunRmep2CfIz3V02Ytblz2ADBW4STfMJmhEzuJZCI45gCr0tlBuntDCKyi_PazolDHdPUuC6mW1iiZf1slfJe2Z7wzwHcJf1xuKEA/s1600/better+public+services.png)
Now,
that’s being Smart on Crime.
References
(1) Morrison, Bronwyn, Identifying and Responding
to Bias in the Criminal Justice System: A Review of
International
and New Zealand Research, (Ministry of Justice, November 2007)
(2) John M Beattie, Crime and the Courts in
England (Princeton University Press, 1986) p. 469.
(3) Braithwaite, John ‘Crime, Shame and
Reintegration’ Cambridge University Press, New York 1989 p.81
(4)
Braithwaite,
John and Peter Drahos, Zero
Tolerance, Naming and Shaming: Is There
a Case for it with Crimes of the Powerful?
Paper to Australian and New Zealand Society of Criminology
Conference, 30 September, 1999, Perth. Portions of this paper appear in an
earlier version in Global
Business Regulation
(5) Workman, Kim ‘The Social Integration of
Maori Prisoners’, A paper presented at the Deakin
University Reintegration Puzzle Conference, Crowne Plaza Hotel, Auckland on the
22nd August 2013. http://www.rethinking.org.nz/assets/Maori%20and%20the%20CJS/130820_The_Social_Integration_of_Maori_Prisoners.pdf
(6)
Uggen,
U., Mamza, J., Behrens, A. (2004) ’Less than the average citizen’: stigma, role
transition and the civic reintegration of convicted felons, in Maruna,S. &
Immarigeon,R. (eds) After Crime and Punishment.
(7)
Workman,
Kim, “How Should we Reintegrate Prisoners? http://www.rethinking.org.nz/assets/Newsletter_PDF/Issue_104/07%20Paper%20on%20Prisoner%20Rentegration.pdf
234 Comments on this Post:
«Oldest ‹Older 1 – 200 of 234 Newer› Newest»Thanks for this great post! I really impressed to read this articles. All K-class motor vehicles meet up with any options that limits the actual weight, powerplant displacement (maximum connected with 660cc) and exterior measurements. Nited kingdom cars and trucks have outstanding price effectiveness come in expanding demand all over the world. car exporters UK
Sometimes it’s good to discharge young offenders without conviction, as sometimes conviction would have adverse consequences. Though Law students are seemed particularly prone to causing minor destruction or drink driving. The average person has little experience in choosing quality representation. A practicing DUI attorney well versed in state DUI law could help them. My brother works as IT admin in a Los Angeles DUI lawyer office and he often tells me how DUI can change someone’s life.
The class will help the individual to realize what he really needs. There is always something that these individuals want to do. The psycho therapist will concentrate on these activities. A frequent criminal can perform a unique job or make a modern action where he can efficiently implement his abilities.Usually, a thief starts stealing something which is rather insignificant
Shoplifting and theft PREVENTION CLASS
Draft a shoplifting policy and enforce it. Post the policy so employees and customers are aware of it. Offer ongoing training for employees so they understand how to prevent shoplifting or how to handle a situation if it does occur.
Shoplifting and theft PREVENTION CLASS
Shoplifting and Theft Prevention classes follow a curriculum that assists the clients in developing a better understanding of the social, financial, and personal ramifications of their behavior. Take a look: [http://www.theftpreventionclass.com] Shoplifting class
If you are looking for a Los Angeles probate lawyer, it can be overwhelming with the amount of advertising online. Just searching on your favorite search engine, will return somewhere in the region of half a million links in the LA County area. However, the best place to check for a reputable organization is the official Los Angeles County Bar Association's lawyer referral service. For more details-los angeles probate lawyer
Thanks for your awesome article posting. I loudly say that it is very excellent. If you are interested to learn about los angeles probate lawyer, United State you can click the above link and visit their website.Please visit los angeles probate lawyer website in los angeles.
los angeles probate lawyer
Thanks for this great post! I really impressed to read this articles. Kidney Care Capsule For Man & For Women I loudly say that it is very excellent
All P.I. lawyers charge a fee for their services. In most cases, the fee is a percentage of the compensation the client receives. Click here for more to know about personal injury attorney
Obat Bopeng Bekas Jerawat Obat Bopeng Bekas Jerawat Obat Bopeng Bekas Jerawat
Obat Lubang Bekas Jerawat
Obat Flek Paru Paru
Penyebab Tuba Falopi Tersumbat
Pantangan Makanan Penderita Prostat
Penyebab Tuba Falopi Tersumbat
Pantangan Makanan Penderita Prostat
Penyebab Tuba Falopi Tersumbat
Pantangan Makanan Penderita Prostat
Penyebab Tuba Falopi Tersumbat
Pantangan Makanan Penderita Prostat
good This proper period can get establish by the end user. official site buttons at the same minute for a period of 2 moments. The users of Casper SnapChat nice.
good no cost to download without the fee. You may easily download Mobdro for XBMC we own presented in this article is merely for putting in the great.
very nice application download it
vidmate for pc
Good Blog
tubemate apk
This Is So Very Nice Post.
Truth or dare
good It is normally no cost emulator. Most important good thing about grey droid4x You can switch the iphone app size (gadget, large mobile or default), nice.
icloud unlock
unlock icloud
iCloud unlock
unlock icloud
bypass icloud lock
unlock iphone
iCloud unlocking
icloud unlock
unlock icloud
bypass icloud lock
Best Pocket Knife
Best Folding Knife
Folding Knives
good that you can enjoy the film or a present afterwards. check this site and Voot children for special children shows vootdownloadapp nice.
I really love this post very much as it as some great tips. Joint Pain Relief Codes PDF
Thanks for providing such a detail post and I love it also. 7 Steps to Health and The Big Diabetes Lie review
nice post thank you im love queen meet me at cute love quotes
Every man have to be punished for their mistakes.
The Amazing You Review - Revealing Secrets Of This Program
Today my brother is discharging from the jail.
EZ Battery Reconditioning Scam
good immediately without eating or ingesting up space from your machine. Showbox APK a receive it on your Glass windows Laptop or computer release nice.
The court will today announce the final decision.
Ex Factor Guide Review
There is strict laws for those person who drive the car while drinking alcohol.
Obsession Phrases by Kelsey Diamond
Text Your Ex Back Book
We will punish the all people who do crime.
Language of Desire plan
I totally agree with you. If you want my support then let me know. Ways to Get Him Back
Many people don't feel shame when they get punishment.
Get Your Ex Boyfriend Back Fast
good In order to use the current variation of the Wifikill application, http://www.wifikillpro.com Then launch the app and also it will certainly request best.
semana santa argentina fechas
2017 semana fechas
good these unsafe programs. We try to offer secure, intriguing ifacetimeapp It can be found, it is offered in all the apple iphone versions nice.
A settled lodging credit financing cost is another famous decision by the individuals who are looking for home loan advances since it is not influenced by monetary changes on the planet advertise. The individuals who pick this home loan rate bundle will keep on paying a settled rate of premium paying little mind to how the world market is getting along for the term of the home loan credit. car title loans
good As I already stated that, iTube is not offered on Play shop iTube Smartphones are made to resemble your laptop and nice.
Settle on an expert. At the point when the upsetting weight of the enormous home credit reimbursements shows signs of improvement of you it is normal to pick the most straightforward decision of the parcel. payday loans chicago
do choi tinh duc
good It will capture and get into the iOS device Mobdro for Apple which helps people to watch out the free movies as streams.
bọc răng sứ thẩm mỹ
Trồng răng implant
Nha khoa uy tín
Chỉnh nha là gì
Nha khoa hà nội
good download a massive variety of cost-free apps and various Google Play Store for PC Download Windows 8.1/10/7 Free account qualifications, you also should create a new Android nice.
Thanks your topic, pleas click my website https://lozi.vn/
Thanks your topic, pleas click my website LOZI.VN , tim nha tro o tphcm , dang tin cho thue nha tro mien phi
Thanks your topic, pleas click my website https://lozi.vn/
Thanks you for sharing. visit my website: Dự đoán tỷ số bóng đá hôm nay and Xem bóng đá trực tuyến hôm nay
dự án millennium quận 4
Thoải mái dưới ngón chân của bạn. Sàn gỗ công nghiệp tại hà nội có trong một mảng vô số các màu sắc và phong cách cho giao diện và cảm giác bạn muốn. Kết cấu được sang trọng, thiết kế riêng, hoặc mô hình để đưa ra các nhân cách của hầu hết các phòng. Thiết kế của chúng tôi sẽ giúp bạn xem lại các lựa chọn tốt nhất cho Sàn gỗ Thái Lan tại Hà nội - với phong cách và ngân sách mong muốn của bạn
thiet ke web/ thiet ke web ban hang
Thanks for your share. But I think some peole don't feel shame when they get punishment.
mua bán đàn organ ở biên hòa
Dịch vụ gia hạn visa giá rẻ tại Tp. Hồ Chí Minh. Chúng tôi chuyên các dịch vụ visa cho người Việt Nam và người nước ngoài. Mọi chi tiết xin liên hệ: 091.594.6427 - Mr.Sang (Call, Zalo, Viber) . Địa chỉ: 268 Cộng Hòa, phường 13, quận Tân Bình, Hồ Chí Minh.
Ngoài ra chúng tôi còn các dịch vụ khác như:
1/ Làm visa đi tất cả các nước.
2/ Gia hạn visa Việt Nam cho người nước ngoài.
3/ Làm công văn quốc tịch khó.
4/ Làm thẻ tạm trú.
5/ Làm visa Trung Quốc cho người Việt Nam.
6/ Làm visa Hàn Quốc cho người Việt Nam.
7/ Dịch vụ xin công văn nhập cảnh cho người nước ngoài. (kể cả quốc tịch khó)
Với phương châm "Đặt uy tín lên hàng đầu", công ty Visa Thái Dương chúng tôi tự tin là đơn vị cung cấp dịch vụ gia hạn visa giá rẻ hàng đầu Sài Gòn.
<br
Thanks for your share.
There are several people who constantly experience the sensation that they have to choose up something
That's good idea. There are several people who constantly experience the sensation that they have to choose up something
Thanks for your tips.
You can visit my page:
DNservice
muabanmaylanhtaidanang
suamaylanhtaidanang
suamaygiattaidanang
Introducing the service of repairing hot water tanks at prestigious and good quality 2017 -In addition, the center will also share the experience of repairing defects in the 2017 heaters, which you can refer to here.
Suabinhnonglanhtaihanoi suabinhnonglanhtaihanoi
fund by church loan in USA is a blessing for churches who need financial support temporarily. But it must be a right and fair charging and also an expert one to make experience better.
These kind of post are always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post, writing is simply great, thank you for the post.
car service alexandria va
After you download and install the application, you should produce musicallylogin.co If you are using an Android tool you have to Download and install Musical.ly Apk.
I enjoyed reading your blog. Where to apply for church loans in USA is a query to many churches. I will recommend those churches to analyze the reviews of lenders first and then to take the decision.
The article makes sense, thanks for sharing. Please visit my Website: sua binh nong lanh tai ha noi
Thanks for the useful information, I will visit the website regularly
http://thietkewebbatdongsan.org/thiet-ke-website/
giảm cân bằng trà bồ công anh giảm cân với trà bồ công anh trà bồ công anh giảm cân
nice post and thank you for share this link!!!!
imo for pc is of the best video calling application for free of cost.imo for pc is the best application.
Related search keyword
imo for MAC
imo download for pc
imo Apk
imo for ios
imo Download
Download imo
imo for pc latest
imo App
Android users do not need to loiter the internet for Facetime app. If you are an Android user then go and grab your best alternative from facetimeappdownload.com
xmodgamesdownloads.com
vshare
www.worldcupthemesong.org
fifaworldcup2018song.com
fifaworldcup2018livestreams.com
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام تقدم اهم هذة النصائح
يجب ان تقوم ربة المنزل بتنظيف الاثاث من كنب ومجالس وغيرهم بشكل يومي وتنظيفهم من الاتربة لعدم تراكم الاتربة وبالتالي يصعب ازالتها مع الوقت .
افضل شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض تنصح ايصا بالاهتمام بتنظيف الستائر وغسيل الموكيت والسجاد بشكل مستمر للحفاظ علي رونقها ونظافتها واناقتها كما اننا ننصح بالتخلص من الاشياء التي ليس لها اي اهمية اوقيمة لعدم التراكم الزايد عن اللزوم .
كما اننا ننصح بالاهتمام بالتنظيف الدوري للمطبخ بكل مافية لعدم تراكم الدهون ومن ثم يصعب ازالتها فيما بعد والاهتمام بتنظيف الصحون اول بأول لعدم جلب الحشرات والروائح الكريهة وايضا الحمام لابد من تنظيفةو تعقيمة بشكل دوري لصحتك وصحة اسرتك مع استخدام المطهرات الفعالة .
شركة تنظيف فلل بالرياض تنصحك ايضا سيدتي بالاهتمام بنظافة الشبابيك الداخلي والخارجي لانة يعطي لمسة جمالية رائعة للفيلا الخاصة بك وتشعرك بالراحة عن نظفاتها .
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف منازل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالدمام
IPL 2018 Live Streaming
FIFA Womens World Cup 2019 Live Streaming
Cricket reviews
latest Cricket updates
upcoming Cricket matches
Watching live matches from your home with your family/friends is a great feeling. In addition to that if you watch such amazing games for free, then your excitement doubles. Therefore watch all the International games like NFL, NBA, Soccer, MLB, NHL, WWE, UFC, Golf, etc like here. The best way of streaming such channels for free is possible by sportsraefree app.
Therefore, download sportsarefree xyz v2.0 apk for android.
www.nhadepvip.com
http://nhadepvip.com/gia-gach-3d-bao-nhieu-31691u.html
while studying this article i was in shocked. because of the author explained the story narration is extraordinary. you will also get same feeling if you can read this article. thank you for sharing article. you people will watch this types of articles from Redbox TV for Mac.
Nice story to study. good article. thanks for sharing.
best android games.
Very Good and great share awesome...!!
visit here
Công ty chuyên thiết kế website tại Thanh Hóa giá rẻ chuyên nghiệp http://doiseo.weebly.com/thiet-ke-website/thiet-ke-web-tai-thanh-hoa-uy-tin-chuyen-nghiep
It's really Very smart crime. i was shocked while reading this article. thanks for sharing this article. you get more videos like this you can install or download best streaming application ever that is Download Terrarium TV for iPad Air.
Best Alternatives of Mini Militia
Đơn vị khắc dấu tại Thanh Hóa uy tín http://doiseo.weebly.com/in-nam-my/on-vi-khac-dau-cong-ty-tai-thanh-hoa-uy-tin | In thiệp cưới tại Thanh Hóa giá rẻ http://doiseo.weebly.com/in-nam-my/dich-vu-in-thiep-cuoi-gia-re-tai-thanh-hoa
Informative article.
Kiến Trúc Cộng - Công ty Kiến trúc sư Đà Nẵng chuyên tư vấn, thiết kế, xây dựng trọn gói nhà phố, nhà đẹp 2 tầng 3 tầng giá rẻ, quán cafe, biệt thư, nội thất quán cafe, phòng khách, văn phong làm việc... tại đà nẵng.
Dịch vụ thiết kế
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-nha-pho
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-quan-cafe
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-biet-thu
http://kientruccong.vn/noi-that-van-phong
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-phong-khach
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-nha-bep
http://kientruccong.vn/thiet-ke-phong-ngu
Hey!!
also check it and xmodapk Download
Very Nice Article keep sharing this post kindly check
windows 7 duplicate
I dont like he
https://www.reddit.com/user/suanonnhapkhau/
https://www.pinterest.com/suanonnhapkhau/
https://twitter.com/suanonnhapkhau/
http://profile.hatena.ne.jp/suanonnhapkhau/
Yes, thank you
https://plus.google.com/u/0/107071248717244582656/
https://www.facebook.com/Mai-Ton-Dep-Ha-Noi-403056213519309
https://twitter.com/maitondephanoi
This is extremely awesome article and instructive post mercifully check
Epsxe For pc
it was really very interesting information dear. great article.
Flipaclip is one of the best cartoon animation application for you. click here for more information.
www.flipacliponline.com/flipaclip-for-windows/.
www.flipacliponline.com/flipaclip-ios-iphone-ipad/.
Get unlimited movies or videos are here for you. titanium tv is one of the best streaming application for free watching.
titaniumtv.me/
www.titaniumtv.me/titanium-tv-app-download-latest-version/.
Get unlimited movies are here for you dear.
Cyberflix TV Firestick.
cyberflixtv.me/.
I learned a lot from the blog post. Thank you for sharing!
instagram hashtags
really awesome information dear. get unlimited movies for your iOS devices.
http://www.tvtapios.co/tvtap-pro-for-windows-1078-laptop/.
http://www.tvtapios.co/tvtap-pro-on-firestick-fire-tv/.
apps like kinemaster
kinemaster without watermark
kinemaster old version
kinemaster chroma key
kinemaster whatsapp status
kinemaster new version
kinemaster for windows phone
kinemaster video layer
Kingroot for PC
Kingroot apk
Kingroot for ios
Kingroot alternatives
Kingroot for mac
Download Whatsapp 2019
Download Whatsapp 2019 Apk
Download WhatsApp 2019 for Mac
Download WhatsApp 2019 For Windows PC
Download WhatsApp 2019 For Windows Phone
Download WhatsApp Business 2019 APK
Thank you for the post.
the players klub iptv
itubeapp.info
I am reading a blog on this website for the first time and I would like to tell you that the quality of the article is up to the mark it is very well written. Thank you so much for writing this article and I will surely read all the blogs from now on. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers.
FIFA WWC 2019 Live Stream
FIFA Women's World Cup 2019 Live Streaming - Match Schedule & Fixture, TV Schedule, Points Table, Live Score, Watching Live Online TV Stream.
Get the Best furniture sale
2019 cricket world cup live stream
cricket world cup live stream england
cricket world cup live stream australia
apk link
Google Chrome 2020
Google Chrome 2020 APK
Google Chrome 2020 Latest Version
Google Chrome 2020 for Windows 10
Google Chrome 2020 for Windows 8
Google Chrome 2020 for Windows 7
Google Chrome 2020 for Windows 64 bit
Google Chrome 2020 for Windows 32 bit
I hope to see more updates from you, this is what I want to find.
imgrum
The different region from various TV channels will cover this whole tournament. Here I will share some TV channels and Live Streaming portal through these links crazy fans will enjoy the most. Let’s see those TV channels whose got the permission to broadcast this Rugby World Cup 2019 Live Streaming free.
KineMaster for pc
KineMaster for mac
KineMaster for ios
KineMaster apk
KineMaster pro for pc
KineMaster for laptop
KineMaster without watermark
KineMaster chroma key
Apps like kinemaster
KineMaster video layer
I needed to thank you for this incredible read!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it. I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post.
picdove
Great post again! Through with this content BLACK WOMEN CELEBRITIES you have given stand out introduction. Appreciate the value.
This post is so impressive okka no yuusha season 2 Thank you for this article!.
This is the really great post, I like Star Wars Jacket Mens
The article you have shared with us is very nicely written and the message is clear. Thank you so much for sharing this article with us. I really appreciate your hard work.
Danezon
This post is so impressive. watchcartoononline rick and morty season 3 Thank you for this article!..
Awesome identify to visit michelle phan boyfriend to experience the natural life.
This is the really great post, I like Sonic the Hedgehog Jacket
شركة كشف تسربات المياه المعتمدة لدى الشركة الوطنية شركة كشف تسربات المياه المعتمدة لدى الشركة الوطنية
اسرع شركة شحن من الرياض الى مصر اسرع شركة شحن من الرياض الى مصر
شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض شركة عزل خزانات بالرياض
عزل فوم بالرياض عزل فوم بالرياض
اسعار كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض اسعار كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
download line 2020 apk
download skype 2020 apk
download viber messenger 2020 apk
download telegram 2020 apk
download michat 2020 apk
download imo messenger 2020 apk
download kakaotalk 2020 apk
download facebook messenger 2020 apk
download facebook 2020 apk
Whatsapp 2020
I always found very much interesting content on your posts. keep posting, thanks for sharing us and giving us your precious time. Movies Jackets
https://aboutallpet.com/
Through this process his father, whānau and community must share in his shame and indignity. But overriding all that, will be a collective desire for Korotangi to take responsibility, be held accountable; safe in the knowledge that at all times he will have the support of all of Tainui in beating a difficult and lengthy path back to redemption. Some years later these young miscreants emerged as solid citizens, making both a positive contribution to society and lots of money, successfully representing the next generation of the legal profession who had fallen afoul of the law.
Envision Techno Social Media Agency
Browse Our Range Of Men's Leather Jackets. Shop Leather Jackets For Men With Custom Made To Measure Option. Free Shipping In USA & World Wide.
Our signature biker jackets are crafted from leather and suede with metal trims. Explore our men's collection with free delivery on US orders over $250 & free US ...
Free Shipping, Free Returns! Shop Authentic Black Leather Jackets For Men and Women and plus more fashion apparel including trench coats, hoodies and ..
People have their own ideas about what to wear, some like jackets and other outfits from famous Hollywood Film Jackets to fulfill their desires. In order to do so, ...
good post aboutpetguide
Our Academic writing service is most amazing service and reasonable service. Our Assignments are always a hassle, especially when there are too many of them. Services
I hope to see more updates from you, this is what I want to find. living room furniture
. The pair will commotion it out for the welterweight title. The current featherweight champion Alexander UFC 251 How To Watch Volkanovski is furthermore scheduled to defend his title for the first era against his former enemy, Max Holloway at UFC 251. The Australian champion claimed the fashion adding from Blessed, along with at UFC 245 coarsely December 14, 2019 back a unanimous decision victory.
Our Academic writing service is most amazing service and reasonable service. Our Assignments are always a hassle, especially when there are too many of them.
Diy
Door Windows
Doors And Windows
Furniture
Flooring Roofing
revistaneon/
i read your article. that was really awesome information and get unlimited movies also.
OneBox HD | Download OneBox HD App on Android, iOS & PC.
Download MegaIPTV Official latest 3.0.2 Android APK
Showbox APK Download - Latest ShowBox 5.35 For Android
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
Money Gadget
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your website. It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a designer to create your theme?
She additionally saves the school theater for cheer work and worn a stylish Glee Cheerios Red Jacket , leaving Glee Club without a spot to perform.
Emily In Paris Coats Collection from Movies jackets
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea.
data science course in India
If you are looking for Dream team for today's match, then Kheltalk is the best for you. Here you find Today cricket match prediction and see the latest updates, news, information much more. Kheltalk helps you to win and earn more in Dream11 matches. Make your team and lead in your match.
The Queen’s Gambit Beth Harmon Sweater This is very nice and wonderful blog so informative
Great Article. You have beautifully articulated it. Readers revisit only if they found something useful. So the core formula is to provide value to the readers. Also, Title is very important. Cyberpunk 2077 Jacket | Make It Easy
“I purchased this book for my mom for Mother’s Day and her reaction was priceless. I shared the emotional video with the author Mrs. Felicia Harris. My mom couldn’t stop crying.
Book about me
Thanks for sharing very informative blog ..... story line is very nice to read it out .....
Leather Jackets
Extraordinary Article. You have wonderfully expressed it. Peruses return to just in the event that they discovered something valuable. So the center recipe is to offer some benefit to the per users. Additionally, Title is vital The Falcon and the Winter Soldier Outfits
Amazing website, Love it. Great work done.
Hi i,am Selling Home Decors If you want a luxuries trendy look for your bedroom Online dreamcovers Bed Sheets.
Follow Our Website https://dreamcovers.com.au/
what is csm
watch all Turkish Dramas with English Subtitles free of cost.
On our website you can watch all old and latest turkish dramas with English Subtitles. Visit our website and watch
https://turkishsub.su/
It's great to see this post. I really appreciate your work Oujeer - Women Vest
really infomative and eduvcative article thanks publisher for sharing this info with us character voice generator
Thanks for sharing this best stuff with us! Keep sharing! I am new in the blog writing.dr martens au
Spot on with this write-up, I truly think this website needs much more consideration. I’ll probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info.
Ayo Bali
Wisata Bali
AyoBali
After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.
Bandoeng.co.id
Bandung
Wisata Bandung
This post is very informative, I like chuck greene jacket I am interested in reading this post.
There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith.
I don?t know if best practices have emerged around things like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel the impact of just a moment’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
Ayobali.net
Ayo Bali
Wisata Bali
Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!
Click Here
Visit Web
Cmidonostia.es
There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made certain nice points in features also.
Click Here
Visit Web
Forosx.com
I have been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me. Personally, if all site owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before. Tom Hiddleston Loki 2021 TVA Jacket
womens leather jackets has emerged as the top-pick of every fashionista! Buy our amazing collection of unique and stylish designs this season and boost your style game with an exciting roll out!
After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Would you be interested in exchanging links?
Click Here
Visit Web
Palipreschool.org
Great post. Articles that have meaningful and insightful comments are more enjoyable, at least to me. It’s interesting to read what other people thought and how it relates to them or their clients, as their perspective could possibly help you in the future. adidas nmd r1 womens
AOL Mail Login is the ultimate software that provides its users with a free web-based email service to help them enjoy a secure and magnificent email experience. nike air vapormax biegowe
Hello! I would want to offer a enormous thumbs up to the great info you might have here with this post. We are returning to your site for additional soon. nike air max 90 udsalg
Gemini is a well-known cryptocurrency exchange with a user-friendly design and verified security for US Dollar accounts. nike air vapormax flyknit 2 bestellen
You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!
Ihubbub
Website
Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article.Oujeer - Men Vest
Amazing work. Appreciate it for this grand post. Such a nice information journalist killed in afghanistan.
I was just examining through the web looking for certain information and ran over your blog.It shows how well you understand this subject.
ServiceNow Training in Pune
Hy i'm designer for Customize leather jackets. Please visit our website. Yellowstone Rip Wheeler Faux Leather Jacket
I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this web page who has shared this wonderful paragraph at this place
servicenow training and placement in hyderabad
Hello! I just would like to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.
Irisbolling.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss. Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx
List.ly
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
This is a leather jacket made from pure sheepskin made specifically for women. Such jackets consist of a double-sided button and waist. Virgin River Melinda Monroe Shearling Jacket
Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.
Voyage-mondial.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Excellent article, Thanks for sharing this article.
Ubs accounting
Myob Singapore
Skill future accounting software
Best Accounting software Singapore
Would you be interested in exchanging links?
Fitday.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Very nice post, i certainly love this website, keep on it
Ask.fm
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Pakistan Business News
It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!.
If you set out to make me think today; mission accomplished! I really like your writing style and how you express your ideas. Thank you. Mold Inspections in Cooper City
RightJackets is the best place for you to get the most original custom made products and more.We have the biggest range of a variety of products.
Calf Skin Brown Leather Jacket
HUF Reversible Silver Easy Satin Jacket
Casual Purple Motorcycle Leather Jacket
God Created Adam & Eve Not Adam & Steve Jacket
Ladies Brando Green Fitted Suede Leather Jacket
Would you be interested in exchanging links?
Community.onsen.io
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
Wow such a shocking substance I never broke down this before keep it up and continue to accommodate us more strong data. Truly research this now Yellowstone Jackets and benefit it.
I truly taught here on your site. I can't fight the impulse to investigate the way wherein you outlined this thought. Particularly your site manager is genuinely astounding with this work. Can barely clutch hear your reaction as I'm attempting to take a gander at extra with you. I really need to perceive that you review me Nasa jacket
Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get something done.
Forum.singaporeexpats.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web
If we talk about the crime rate that we can say that nowadays it is so increased because of the we can see our outside it was so increased then we should go for the What is VMware cloud foundation that are provided some storages and free software.
I read this articles with my best friend that was so good to me apart from this i also go for the mcdonalds menu prices india that was needed for the indian people.
Nice Information Keep it Up! We are provide the best House Shifting Services in Karachi
https://karachimovers.com/
Its a really interesting and informative article for me. I appreciate your work and skills.top gun jacket for sale
Kunden konnten Artikel aus dem neuesten Pink 2-Kapselsortiment der Marke auswählen und erhielten nach Abschluss der Transaktion eine Schließfachnummer und einen Code. Die Marke präsentierte auch ihre neue Tasche, tweed anzug die Bambino Long. Die Idee ist, Grenzen in der Luxuswelt zu sprengen , sagte Jacquemus, wie von Dazed Digital berichtet. "Darum geht es bei Jacquemus." Dies ist nicht das erste Mal, dass Automaten einen Ausflug nadelstreifenanzug in die Mode machen. Letztes Jahr hat & Other Stories einen In-Store-Automaten vorgestellt, um seine neuesten Beauty-Linien zu verkaufen.
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! nike air vapormax flyknit 2 bestellen
I appreciate this blog your blog is vert help full for me i really enjoyed this stuff dude. adidas nmd r1
Sports Betting at Safest Betting Sites in Israel - Airjordan10 RetroOutlet
Safest Betting Sites in Israel · air jordan 18 retro racer blue to good site The Best air jordan 18 retro racer blue to me and Best Betting air jordan 18 retro yellow my site Sites in the UK · The UK's Hottest Bookmakers · 바카라 Betfair Sports Betting Authority air jordan 18 retro men red clearance · Betfair
MMORPG OYUNLAR
instagram takipçi satin al
tiktok jeton hilesi
tiktok jeton hilesi
antalya saç ekimi
referans kimliği nedir
İnstagram Takipçi Satın Al
mt2 pvp
takipci satin al
With Toronto Airport Taxi you can enjoy your most comfortable taxi ride, in style. This is the best way to get around without worry or stress. Drivers are punctual and professional.
AC Taxi Service in Toronto is a quality scratch car service, trusted by millions around the world from the Toronto International Airport and the Greater Toronto Area to some of the most popular tourist destinations and Airports in North America.
I just love seeing cherry blossom. Thanks a lot for sharing the great information!
Your article contains information that is not available anyplace else. It is my sincere wish that you persist to write such wonderful posts Famous Movie Jacket
Oujeer is a leading brand for leather jackets & handcraft custom leather vest motorcycle
This is the first time that I visit here. I found so many exciting matters in this particular blog armreif
Yes, I am a recovering clothing shopaholic. Perhaps you think clothing shopaholics are just women who can't control their urge to spend money on clothes. bolso mujer
This was an extremely wonderful post. Thanks for providing this info bracciale di perle
Post a Comment