Thursday, 15 May 2014

The ‘Leading Justice’ Symposium - Well-staged - Great Reviews – But Where were the Audience?


by Kim Workman

“All over the place, from the popular culture to the propaganda system, there is constant pressure to make people feel that they are helpless, that the only role they can have is to ratify decisions and to consume.”
Noam Chomsky

 In July 2013, Treasury produced an excellent report, ‘Windows of Opportunity to Deliver Better Justice Sector Outcomes over the Long Term’.  (1)  Its advice has been seminal in guiding the Better Public Service (BPS) Reducing Crime and Reoffending Strategy.  However, Treasury’s advice to   tell a clear and compelling story on justice sector performance, focussing more on what is being achieved and less on how services are provided’, has been misinterpreted.  
This advice has led the Justice sector to provide regular media updates on its success in reducing crime and reoffending, but very little information on how that has been achieved.  As a result, the paying public are feeling increasingly detached from the action – a little like going to a play, but only being allowed to watch the ending and join in the applause. 
The format is well established, and it is difficult to recall an occasion in recent times, when a Justice Sector Minister or a Justice Sector CEO has not preceded a speech without reference to the BPS results – to the point that people are tiring of it.  They want some meat with their potatoes.  If the story is to be ‘clear and compelling’, then the public need to understand not only what has been achieved, but how. 
The Leading Justice Symposium, the most recent Justice Sector event, was a case in point.  It is not often that some of the world’s leading experts on crime prevention and control are gathered in one place, to take part in a high level symposium.  The Minister of Justice  Hon Judith Collins, publicly announced the forum, just two days before it was held.
On the day before the Symposium, the Minister announced the latest BPS results, declaring the lowest crime rate since 1978.  Rethinking took the trouble to point out that in 1978 the imprisonment rate was 88 per 100,000 population, compared to about 200 per 100,000 today, and that the next BPS goal should be to reduce the prison population
 The Symposium addressed four key issues:
  • Global and Domestic Trends
  • New Zealand’s Justice Sector in 2024
  • What the NZ Justice sector should focus on now to reduce the 2024 crimescape
  • How the justice sector should respond to reduce victimisation and support future victims.
The Symposium, which  was opened with a speech by the Ministerincluded eight international justice sector experts, who were asked to provide the Government with fresh thinking around reducing crime and victimisation, including  new issues such as cyber-bullying, identity theft, hacking, and online stalking – concepts unheard of a generation ago.
 

The crime experts invited were well chosen for the task – most had backgrounds in what is now called crime science; the study of crime in order to find ways to prevent it. Three features distinguish crime science from the traditional approach to criminology in that it:
  1. Focuses on cutting crime;
  2. Focuses on crime rather than criminals; and
  3. Relies on scientific methodology rather than social theory.
Crime Science is an interesting development in the field of criminology, and had its first public incarnation when the  Jill Dando Institute of Crime Science was formed in 2001.  The Institute  is established in the Engineering Sciences Faculty, with growing ties to the physical sciences such as physics and chemistry but also drawing on the fields of statistics, environmental design, forensics, policing, economics and geography.  It is increasingly popular with politicians, as it avoids having to take responsibility for shortcomings in social policy.  As with most new developments, there are acolytes who regard crime science as the holy grail, and would prefer to see it separated from social theory and criminology, rather than as a valuable part of an integrated whole.

 
Not so the crime science experts chosen for this symposium .  Dr Gloria Laycock, was the first Director of the Jill Dando Institute and is an expert on situational crime prevention, and among other things, repeat victimisation.  Professor Betsy Stanko is a world leader in violence prevention, and well known for her ability to take social science research beyond academia and use the evidence to guide public policy.  Another expert, Professor Russell G. Smith is the Principal Criminologist at the Australian Institute of Criminology and has specialties in global, economic and electronic crime trends.

 
The mix of topics was indicative of where the government may be placing its emphasis – repeat victimisation, and domestic and sexual violence are likely to be high priorities in the future.  When experts get together, the dialogue can get a little stratospheric  - but by all accounts Sir Mark Solomon’s contribution to the discussion -  typically honest, heartfelt and blunt -  returned participants momentarily to ground level.  Dr Kim McGregor’s speech  on sexual violence was made publicly available.

 
The following day, the Justice Minister of Justice advised the public that the symposium was an outstanding success, and that in the view of Dr Gloria Laycock, New Zealanders were the best in the world at ‘fighting crime’. She then wandered from the approved script and  attributed the reduction in crime to ‘stiffer sentencing’ – a view unconnected to any evidence, either in New Zealand or internationally.2 Government also announced a $10.4m boost in sexual violence funding.  This was indeed a lightning response to  public criticism by Dr Jackie Blue, Human Rights Commissioner  for Women.  Dr Blue, a former National MP, submitted to the Social Services Select Committee on 2 April that the funding gaps for sexual violence victims were a blemish on human rights, and produced the submission to the inquiry into the funding of specialist sexual violence social service in support.

 
The Symposium  was a masterful production, with a stellar cast, slick marketing and a happy ending.  We didn’t witness the production, but by all accounts, the producers deserve our applause and support.

 
Perhaps the most interesting insights came from Dr Gloria Laycock, the star player, who escaped the theatre long enough to be interviewed by Andrea Vance, recently voted Reporter of the Year.  In the article, “Politicians Can’t Take Credit for Crime Drop’  (Dominion Post 3 May 14).(3)  Dr Laycock  pointed out that politicians can’t take credit for the crime drop. and that:

  • The plummeting crime rate is an international trend, and due more to science and technology than political strategy.  Technology such as home security systems and central locking systems in cars have fuelled a drop in youth crime.
  • The New Zealand Police focus on crime prevention was outstanding.  However, the court system should adopt a similar ‘problem solving’ approach, e.g. drug courts.   
  • The rest of the criminal justice system needs to move away from a focus on punishment, retribution and sentencing. 
  • Reductions in family violence and child abuse was not necessarily a good thing, as those crimes are seriously under-reported.  In that situation, an increase in reported offending should be regarded as a positive    (In New Zealand, only about 10% of all family violence and child abuse incidents and child abuse cases are reported to the Police.)

Professor Laycock ‘s comments  teach a valuable lesson.   If we accept that all is well in the world of criminal justice then we can fail to more closely question and examine the effectiveness of what is being done.

 
In Rethinking’s view, Treasury advice to focus on outcomes rather than activity, needs to be balanced against other advice in the same report; i.e. that in order to be successful, ‘Consensus across the sector and with the wider public about how best to deliver the aims of a safe and just society is required.” (p. 12)

 
The Treasury Minister, the Hon Bill English, has gone further.  He recently stressed the importance of consulting not only with the public, but with justice consumers.  In a recent speech to the Institute of Public Administration, (3) he urged public servants to focus more strongly on clients and customers.



The public service and politicians run the risk of losing respect for the people for whom we are providing services. To combat that, we will increasingly ask, “Do we really understand the nature of our interaction with the general public, and our customers?” “Do we really understand how the behaviour of public institutions impacts on those people, and have we asked them?”

 
As an example, he talked about the importance of treating prisoners as customers;

“………. That is going to mean more sitting down and understanding our customers, for example the newly- released prisoner who is potentially a very expensive individual in our community because he is likely to end up back in a very expensive system. Do we know how he thinks and what his aspirations are?”
 

Getting Wider Public Consensus 

The best way to get ‘wide public consensus’  is to engage the public in the conversation.  When the next ‘Leading Justice’ symposium is held, the Ministry of Justice could also hold a   public symposium or conference, featuring the international experts,  who would be available to share their knowledge with the 'wider public', and respond to questions.   The Ministry will hopefully  publish proceedings from the Symposium,  but reading about other peoples’ decisions, is not quite the same thing as being party to the dialogue.
 

This recommended approach not only reflects Treasury advice, but is also Smart on Crime.  

 References:
  1. NZ Treasury . ‘Windows of Opportunity to Deliver Better Justice Sector Outcomes over the Long Term’-   Background Paper for the 2013 Statement on the Long Term Fiscal Position, July 2013.
  2. P. Gendreau, C. Goggin and F.T. Cullen (1999). The Effects of Prison Sentences on Recidivism, Ottawa: Solicitor General of Canada.
  3. Hon Bill English, Speech to the Institute of Public Administration, 20 Feb 2014


43 Comments on this Post:

custom thesis writing service said...

One of the most recognized legal symbols visible in the architecture of the Supreme Court Building is the female figure representing Justice, who is depicted in three sculptural groups.

yuvikhan said...

good great deal even more in your Mobile phone Cell phones or Tablets. check this site employ our provided lively download links to Download Mobdro great.

Williams said...

Very informative post. thank You for sharing.

dissertation writing help

harrymackay said...

good One of the interesting features of Google Duo apk Google Duo App user interface so that the consumer can simply nice.

gleason ricardo said...

good You might make an effort something like Tunebite or Aimersoft DRM Multimedia Converter. itunes for android Merely copy your music data files from the computer system to your phone's music folder nice.

Mishra Suraj said...


We are only concerned in making our services better, and serving our customers nicely.
Hyderabad Packers and Movers
Bangalore Packers and Movers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-hyderabad

Mishra Suraj said...


We shift your belongings quickly and efficiently by incorporating top-quality packaging material, dedicated staff, world-class technology.
Mumbai Packers and Movers
Pune Packers and Movers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-mumbai

Mishra Suraj said...


We are here to shift your valuable and precious house hold goods to your destination.
Delhi Packers and Movers
Gurgaon Packers and Movers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-delhi

Neil Jakson said...

Hi, your post is very interesting and This advice has led the Justice sector to provide regular media updates on its success in reducing crime and reoffending, but very little information on how that has been achieved. As a result, the paying public are feeling increasingly detached from the action – a little like going to a play, but only being allowed to watch the ending and join in the applause...
Cheap Dissertation Writing Service

audreybphillips said...

good new upgrade today. The most recent variation of the Play Shop is Google Play Store stability enhancements. situation you are uninformed great.

audreybphillips said...

Great Maintains often accessed video clip websites, Vidmate APK immediate in you smartphone. It is simple to Fine.

Kate Morey said...

Thank you for the review. it is very interesting . I hope that after the symposium there will be positive changes. Check out this service cause handmadewritings.com provides you writing papers service

Thomas pedro said...

Merchants and their specialists regularly express the mentality that the Buyer's financing is the Buyer's issue, not theirs. Maybe, yet encouraging Buyer's financing ought to unquestionably hold any importance with Sellers. What number of offer exchanges will close if the Buyer can't get financing? Payday Loans

Neil Jakson said...

Your blog is so interesting and thought provoking that I could not refrain myself from sharing it with others. Keep it up!
Dissertation writing services

Ethel Graff said...

Great Trending to allow you know just what other http://fildoapp.com and also play them without also opening up the Fine.

UK Essay Writing Service said...

It was really a treat to be in this wonderful blog community, especially when considering the various posts listed on the site. I have moved through several posts and loved them all for the fresh elements included. I often consider reading nice contents from various online sources like this one, moreover it's one of my hobbies. Among the many wonderful articles listed out, I found one more thing and that's not really felt good. I really felt sad to see you in the recent updates in this blog categories and I hope you guys come up with more new things soon.

denisejmorris said...

We recognize the consequences of jailbreaking https://setbeat.org/ English is readily available but just after setup.

Akshi Sharma said...


good your mobile information use in check.State you're out as well as Fildo App – Best Music Streaming App for Android After importing your library of tunes, you'll wish to make certain nice.
https://fildoappdownload.com/

Akshi Sharma said...


nice click here..
Watch Wimbledon online

Akshi Sharma said...

Awesome Information in the post.Thanks for sharing with us...
ssc cgl 2017

Akshi Sharma said...

Click here to get
aptoide for ios

instagram video downloader said...

Thank you very much for the information you shared, it's all I've been looking for

exam said...

playbox hd

exam said...

playbox hd app

exam said...

game guardian app

exam said...

epass

exam said...

you tv player

KERALA HSC RESULT said...

here

KERALA HSC RESULT said...

best free live streaming sites

KERALA HSC RESULT said...

wwe 2k18

KERALA HSC RESULT said...

mini militia pro pack hack

KERALA HSC RESULT said...

my boy apk

David Cyryl said...

A very decent distribute by you my dear companion. I've bookmarked this page and can happen back again following a few days to analyze for pretty much any new posts which you make. Dissertation Proposal Writing Services

Akshi Sharma said...

AMAZING CONTENT....see this

Akshi Sharma said...

NICE SITE.......tea tv apk download

exam said...

free jio 4g mobile phone

Akshi Sharma said...

Click here to get
http://usopen2017live.net/

Green Michel said...

Nike Air Max Shoes
Nike Air Vapormax Flyknit Shoes
Nike Roshe Run Shoes
Nike Air Presto Shoes
Nike Air Force Shoes
Nike Air Huarache Shoes



Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes
Nike Kobe Bryant Basketball Shoes
Nike Kyrie Irving Basketball Shoes
Nike LeBron XIV ID Boots
Nike LeBron XIV ID Boots

CBSE RESULT said...

cinema box ios download

CBSE RESULT said...

download cinema box ios

CBSE RESULT said...

wifikill apk download

opera mani said...




Bigo Live pc

Bigo live Blackberry

Bigo live for laptop

Bigo live for blackberry

Bigo live for ios


mobdro
Download mobdro
mobdro for ios
mobdro for Kodi
mobdro for iphone
mobdro for android
mobdro for apk
mobdro for pc
mobdro for pc

nancycongdon said...

resolve all the problems that you confront with your phones. https://itutuhelper.com the remedy for such problems a lot of the time.On the web page

Post a Comment